Eggnog Sour Recipe

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Cozy Eggnog Sour Recipe, Made Simple

There’s something about cocktails that warm you from the inside out without the heaviness. The Eggnog Sour Recipe does exactly that—it’s a lovely blend of creamy eggnog meeting the bright snap of fresh lemon and whiskey’s comforting bite. I love how this drink balances cozy richness with a refreshing zing, perfect for a slow weekend afternoon or an intimate gathering. You’ll find it surprisingly easy to make, with just a few ingredients that come together quickly. Plus, it’s a great way to enjoy eggnog beyond the usual holiday parties. Pour it over ice, garnish with a lemon wheel and a dusting of nutmeg, and you’ve got a drink that feels both special and approachable. If you’re like me, you appreciate drinks that invite you to slow down and savor every sip. That’s the heart of the Eggnog Sour Recipe—comfort in a glass, but with a splash of bright liveliness.

Ingredient Lowdown

• 2 oz Eggnog: This creamy base provides richness and holiday nostalgia. I like fresh or high-quality store-bought versions for the best flavor.
• 1.5 oz Whiskey (Bourbon or Rye): Adds warmth and depth. Bourbon’s sweetness complements the eggnog beautifully, while rye gives a spicier edge.
• 0.5 oz Fresh Lemon Juice: Brightens and balances the sweetness. Using freshly squeezed juice makes a world of difference here.
• 0.5 oz Simple Syrup: Softens the tartness without overpowering. You can adjust this to taste, especially if your eggnog or lemon juice varies in sweetness or acidity.
• Lemon Wheel (for garnish): Adds a fresh visual pop and subtle zest aroma as you sip.
• Ground Nutmeg (for garnish): A fragrant sprinkle to complement the creamy texture and add extra warmth on the nose.

Set Up for Success

The best part about this Eggnog Sour Recipe is how fast it comes together once you’ve prepped your ingredients. Before you begin, gather your eggnog, whiskey, fresh lemons, and simple syrup. I always like to have my shaker ice-cold—pop it in the freezer for a few minutes or fill it with ice while I prep. This little step helps get that crisp, cold finish.

Step-by-Step: Eggnog Sour Recipe

1. Fill your shaker with fresh ice. I like to use large cubes if I have them—they melt slower, giving you a chill without watering down your drink too soon.
2. Add the eggnog, whiskey, lemon juice, and simple syrup. The eggnog is creamy and smooth, so watch it coat the inside of your shaker—it’s such a comforting sight.
3. Shake vigorously until well chilled. The shaker should sweat on the outside after about 15 seconds; that means your cocktail is perfectly mixed and refreshingly cold.
4. Strain into a rocks glass filled with fresh ice. I love the sound of the pour as it cascades over the ice—almost like a promise of a great sip coming your way.
5. Garnish with a lemon wheel and a sprinkle of ground nutmeg. That nutmeg dust, in particular, adds an inviting fragrance that brings the whole experience to life.

Flavor Twists for Eggnog Sour Recipe

• Swap bourbon for spiced rum for a deeper warm spice character.
• Add a dash of cinnamon syrup instead of simple syrup for cozy spice notes.
• Use orange juice in place of lemon for a sweeter, citrusy roundness.
• Top with a splash of club soda for a light fizz and refreshing finish.
• Garnish with a cinnamon stick or star anise instead of lemon wheel for aromatic flair.

Storage & Make-Ahead Tips

• Mix the eggnog and whiskey portion ahead and store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 2 days.
• Keep simple syrup ready in the fridge; it lasts several weeks and saves prep time.
• Always shake just before serving to keep that fresh, frothy texture and chill.
• Do not freeze eggnog-based cocktails as the texture can become grainy upon thawing.
• Prepare garnishes in advance and keep refrigerated to maintain freshness.

Eggnog Sour Recipe FAQs

• Can I use store-bought eggnog? Absolutely, just give it a shake or stir first to recombine any separated cream. Fresh eggnog is ideal for a richer taste, but good-quality packaged works fine.
• What whiskey works best? Bourbon gives a slightly sweet, mellow flavor, while rye adds spicy notes. I enjoy both—try whichever fits your mood.
• How can I adjust sweetness? Start with the recipe’s amount of simple syrup, then add more or less to suit your taste. Remember, the eggnog itself is sweet, so balance carefully.
• Can I make this drink non-alcoholic? Yes! Swap whiskey for a splash of vanilla extract or a whiskey-flavored syrup for a grown-up, cozy mocktail feel.
• Should I use fresh lemon juice? Fresh juice brightens the flavor dramatically compared to bottled. If fresh isn’t available, bottled will work, but consider cutting back on simple syrup slightly.

Print